^{Photo: Bloomberg News}

Controversy Erupts as Sequoia Partner's Comments Trigger Industry Backlash

Sequoia Capital, one of Silicon Valley’s most powerful venture capital firms, is under pressure from within the startup community to publicly distance itself from comments made by one of its own partners, Shaun Maguire. The backlash stems from a post Maguire shared on X (formerly Twitter) over the weekend, in which he claimed that New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani “comes from a culture that lies about everything,” further alleging that Mamdani is advancing an “Islamist agenda.”

The post, viewed over 5.3 million times by Monday afternoon, was widely condemned as inflammatory and Islamophobic. Maguire, a known supporter of former President Donald Trump, later doubled down in a follow-up video on the platform, defending his original message.

Open Letter Gains Momentum: Hundreds Demand Accountability

In response, nearly 600 founders, CEOs, and tech professionals have signed an open letter addressed to Sequoia’s leadership. The signatories describe Maguire’s remarks as a “deliberate, inflammatory attack” on Mamdani, who recently won the Democratic mayoral primary and identifies as a democratic socialist.

The letter calls on Sequoia to:

• Publicly denounce Maguire’s comments
• Issue a formal apology to Mamdani and Muslim tech founders
• Launch an independent investigation into Maguire’s conduct over the past two years
• Publish and enforce a zero-tolerance policy on hate speech and religious discrimination

The signatories have asked for a formal response from Sequoia by July 14. If not received, they warn that they will escalate the matter through media channels and broader public advocacy.

Notable supporters of the letter include:

• Mudassir Sheikha, CEO of Careem
• Amr Awadallah, CEO of AI firm Vectara
• Abubakar Abid, machine learning researcher at Hugging Face (a Sequoia-backed company)
• Ahmed Sabbah, CEO of fintech startup Telda

In addition, several Y Combinator alumni have added their names to the growing list.

Silence from Sequoia as Political Divides Deepen

As of now, Sequoia Capital has declined to comment on the controversy. Maguire also has not responded directly to interview requests but has stated on X: “You can try everything you want to silence me, but it will just embolden me.”

The controversy has reignited conversations around Sequoia’s internal politics and the industry’s broader stance on social responsibility. Sequoia, which has historically supported both Democratic and Republican causes, finds itself once again at the center of ideological tension.

Former managing partner Doug Leone, who led the firm until 2022 and remains a partner, has been a vocal Trump supporter and Republican donor. After Trump’s reelection victory in 2024, Leone posted, “To all Trump voters: you no longer have to hide in the shadows…..you’re the majority!!”

In contrast, Mike Moritz—Leone’s predecessor—has been a major Democratic donor and vocal Trump critic. In a 2024 Financial Times op-ed, Moritz criticized the tech industry's alignment with Trump, calling it “a mistake” and questioning how investors could overlook his legal controversies.

Current Sequoia leader Roelof Botha has attempted to steer a centrist path. In a 2024 public appearance, Botha emphasized that Sequoia as a firm does not “take a political point of view” and values the right of individual partners to express personal beliefs. However, he did not address whether such views cross ethical or reputational lines when made in a public or hateful context.

Political Lines in the Tech World

Shaun Maguire is no stranger to political controversy. In 2023, he revealed on X that he had donated $300,000 to Trump’s campaign. His comments about Mamdani come amid growing polarization in the tech world over race, religion, and ideology.

Zohran Mamdani, who defeated former Governor Andrew Cuomo in a surprising primary upset, has drawn criticism from business leaders for his progressive platform and strong stance on wealth redistribution and police reform. However, critics of Maguire’s comments argue that political disagreement should never veer into personal or religious attacks.

What’s at Stake for Sequoia

With billions under management and stakes in market-shaping firms such as SpaceX, X (formerly Twitter), and Safe Superintelligence, Sequoia’s reputation holds significant weight across the startup ecosystem. If it fails to respond to this growing backlash, it could alienate a generation of founders and tech leaders increasingly committed to inclusivity and accountability.

The letter’s signees make it clear: “We are watching how Sequoia responds—and so is the rest of the industry.”

As the July 14 deadline approaches, Sequoia’s leadership faces a defining test—not just of its values, but of its future credibility in a diversifying and politically conscious tech landscape.