^{Source: BBC}

Overview

The UK government's recent announcement to tighten immigration rules has raised alarms among business leaders, who fear that the new measures could exacerbate existing labour shortages and hinder economic growth. The policy changes, aimed at reducing net migration, come at a time when sectors like health and social care are heavily reliant on foreign workers.

Government's New Immigration Measures

Prime Minister Keir Starmer's administration has introduced a series of reforms to the UK's immigration policy, including:

• Raising English language requirements for migrants.
• Increasing the residency period required for indefinite leave to remain from five to ten years.
• Ending the issuance of visas for social care workers.
• Mandating university degrees for skilled worker visas.
• Reducing the post-study work visa duration from two years to 18 months.

These measures are part of the government's strategy to "back British workers over cheap overseas labour" and link migration policy with skills to boost economic growth .

Business Community's Response

Industry leaders have expressed concern that the new immigration rules could lead to significant labour shortages, particularly in sectors that have historically depended on migrant workers. The social care sector, for instance, currently has approximately 131,000 vacancies. Care England, representing independent social care providers, warns that the immigration plans could have "serious consequences for a sector already under immense pressure" .

Martin Green, Chief Executive of Care England, stated, "This decision is not a solution. It is a political gesture that treats the symptoms but ignores the disease. Social care is not low-skilled work. It is high-skill, low-pay work that deserves respect, proper recognition, and meaningful investment."

Similarly, the Confederation of British Industry (CBI) and the British Chambers of Commerce have emphasized the need for a balanced approach. While they support boosting training and skills among British workers, they caution that labour shortages cannot be resolved by training alone and that a controlled, responsive immigration system is essential to keep investment flowing into the UK .

Impact on Net Migration and Labour Market

The Office for National Statistics reported that net migration to the UK hit a record 906,000 in the year to June 2023, up from previous estimates. This figure has since fallen to 728,000 in the year to June 2024, partly due to stricter visa rules, such as banning most international students and care workers from bringing dependents .

However, the reduction in migration has raised concerns about the UK's ability to fill critical roles in various industries. The health and social care sectors, in particular, have relied heavily on foreign workers to meet demand. The government's decision to end overseas recruitment for social care visas, with extensions permitted only until 2028, could further strain these sectors .

Political Context and Public Sentiment

The government's immigration reforms come amid increasing pressure to address public concerns over high migration levels. The rise of the Reform UK party, led by Nigel Farage, has intensified the political debate on immigration. Prime Minister Starmer's recent remarks warning that the UK could become an "island of strangers" have drawn criticism for echoing past divisive rhetoric .‍

While the government aims to demonstrate control over immigration, critics argue that the reforms may impair key sectors like healthcare and academia and fail to address underlying issues such as skills shortages and economic inactivity among the UK workforce .

‍

The UK's new immigration policies reflect a significant shift towards prioritizing domestic labour and reducing reliance on foreign workers. However, the potential for exacerbating labour shortages in critical sectors raises questions about the feasibility of these reforms. Balancing the need for controlled immigration with the demands of the labour market will be crucial to ensuring economic stability and growth.

‍