Source: Common Dreams
After a five-year pause, the Trump administration has announced the resumption of wage garnishment and seizure of tax refunds for defaulted federal student loans. This abrupt policy shift comes as a shock to many, particularly those in low-income professions and retirees who are already struggling to make ends meet.
The announcement on April 21 marked a stark departure from the Biden administration’s approach, which focused on relief and financial recovery during the pandemic. More than 42 million Americans currently hold federal student loans, amounting to a staggering $1.6 trillion in outstanding debt. Among them, over 5 million borrowers are already in default, and the Education Department projects that this number could surge to nearly 10 million within months.
According to Linda McMahon, U.S. Secretary of Education, the administration’s stance is clear: "Borrowers should pay back the debts they take on."
However, for people like Jason Collier, a special education teacher from Virginia, this policy means further financial hardship. "Money is tight when you’re a teacher," says Collier, who has been juggling medical bills and raising two children. He fears that garnishing 15% of his wages will make it nearly impossible to cover essential expenses, such as car repairs or unforeseen emergencies.
It’s not just young professionals who are impacted. Marceline Paul, a 68-year-old retiree, faces the prospect of losing 15% of her monthly Social Security benefit to student loan garnishment. Marceline, who worked in healthcare for decades, now relies on a $2,600 monthly Social Security check. After essential expenses, there’s barely enough left to cover her basic needs.
The fear of garnishment has left her feeling trapped and hopeless. "When I saw that email, it made me sick to my stomach," she said, worried that the cutback would force her to cancel home repairs and give up on visiting her home country, Trinidad.
According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, more than 450,000 borrowers aged 62 and older are currently in default on their federal student loans.
The Biden administration had been working on new initiatives to support borrowers, including the SAVE plan (Saving on a Valuable Education). However, GOP-led lawsuits blocked the plan, leaving many in limbo. As a result, borrowers who were expecting reduced payments now face the reality of wage garnishment.
To complicate matters, the Trump administration recently cut around 50% of the Education Department’s staff, including many employees who assisted borrowers. The remaining team is overwhelmed, leading to hours-long phone waits and confusing guidance on repayment options.
For borrowers like Kia Brown, a management analyst at the Department of Veterans Affairs, the challenge isn’t about avoiding payments but navigating a confusing repayment system. After signing up for the SAVE plan, she found that her payment had jumped from $150 to $319 without explanation. Reaching her loan servicer took over two hours, only to receive inconsistent answers.
"The narrative is that people are dodging their payments," Brown said. "But many are just trying to figure out what they owe and how to pay it."
Consumer advocates are calling for a more nuanced approach to student debt collection. James Kvaal, former undersecretary of education, pointed out that most borrowers who default "truly cannot afford to pay." With the cost of living at record highs, even a small wage garnishment can mean choosing between food, housing, or loan repayment.
Nancy Nierman, assistant director of the Education Debt Consumer Assistance Program in New York, emphasized the broader impact: "Withholding income in today’s economy could force families to skip vital expenses."
During the five-year collection pause, many borrowers changed repayment plans, often moving to income-driven options. Now, with the reinstatement of wage garnishment, those changes may lead to confusion and unexpected financial strain.
The Trump administration’s decision to resume collections amid economic instability has drawn criticism from both borrowers and policymakers. As the nation watches how this policy unfolds, many fear it will only worsen the financial precarity of millions of Americans.
For those at risk of wage garnishment, experts recommend:
While the Trump administration’s policy shift aims to enforce debt repayment, the real-world impact on teachers, healthcare workers, and retirees remains significant. Many of those affected are simply trying to survive financially, and the looming garnishments threaten to destabilize their lives further.
This policy change highlights a stark contrast between administrative policy and the realities faced by everyday Americans burdened by student debt.